The Metaverse Tax: Who Really Pays to Keep the Metaverse Up and Running?

Who Really Pays to Keep the Metaverse Up and Running

The metaverse replicated the one thing no one wanted: taxes! 

On April 11, Meta announced its plans to allow creators to sell their own virtual assets on its virtual reality game platform Horizon Worlds. Meta’s CEO Mark Zuckerberg stated that this was an effort to expand the metaverse to the e-commerce realm. While this sounds great, the fact that Meta is planning to take a 47.5% cut on these sales leaves a sour taste in one’s mouth. 

The charge is a combination of Horizon Worlds’ fee (17.5%) and Meta’s hardware platform fee (30%) levied on sales made through Meta’s Quest store (where it sells games for its virtual headsets). Sales of the metaverse certainly make a pretty penny, with a plot of land selling for US$4.3 million on The Sandbox metaverse in 2021. Naturally, with such massive sales taking place on the metaverse, companies would want a cut of the profits. Let’s try to understand how profits are being distributed between companies and creators on the metaverse. 

Charging a cut on the metaverse

With Meta being the reason why the metaverse gained popularity in 2021, it only makes sense to start examining taxation with it. Meta’s VP of Horizon Vivek Sharma says that the company believes the rates being charged are pretty competitive when compared to the market. Other metaverse companies (as well as companies that sell digital assets, like NFTs) have in fact been charging cuts of their own for the sale of assets. For instance, Roblox charges a 30% fee from its users on the money they make from creating virtual assets on the platform and NFT platform OpenSea charges a 2.5% cut on each transaction. Compared to these platforms, Meta’s charges certainly feel steep and not quite as competitive as Sharma stated. 

What’s interesting is that, for the past couple of months, Meta had been actively calling out Apple for charging a 30% from developers on the app stores. Zuckerberg even went as far as to say that they were updating their subscription agreements to help creators earn more. After the announcement of how much Meta was going to charge creators, Apple has fired back about the hypocrisy of the creator-friendly approach Meta previously said it would take. 

This is not to say that charging taxes in the metaverse is a new concept. The first metaverse ever, Second Life, tried to introduce taxes a couple of years ago, only to be met with harsh backlash from its users. Finally, in March this year, Linden Labs (the company behind Second Life) announced that it would charge its users taxes on premium subscriptions, land fees and other recurring billings. 

But, what about the creators?

On the other side of the equation is the creator. Despite generating US$104 billion in 2021, creators themselves get a very small cut of the profits of the traditional creator economy (e.g. TikTok, YouTube and Instagram), with only 4% of creators making livable wages. The new models of income, like virtual assets, were meant to change this and make content production more economically favorable for creators. To a certain extent, they have been favorable to creators—musician Travis Scott has earned US$20 million in merchandise sales on Fortnite. 

But even big creators, like Travis Scott, would notice if platforms were taking away a massive chunk of their earnings. Of course, we cannot ignore that there would be certain governmental taxes, on top of the deductions from platforms, sooner or later when governmental regulations catch up to technological advancements. Some countries, like India, have already announced a 30% tax on virtual assets. If you add up all these taxes, what is the average creator really left with? 

Nobody likes being taxed, that’s for sure. There has been significant outrage on Twitter about Meta’s taxation scheme, with one user saying “You know I thought Zuckerberg had a better vision for the metaverse than ‘Second Life but with higher taxes than Denmark’”. Up until this point, many were looking at the metaverse as a space for growth for various businesses and artists. However, Meta’s taxation plan has certainly cast doubt on to what extent that claim or belief is true. On the bright side, at least, the discussion on taxes finally opens up a conversation on how profitable Meta and other metaverse companies would be and also how much the creators would actually make from the sale of their works. 

Also read:

Header image courtesy of Unsplash


Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email


4 Business Sectors Reaping Profit from FIFA World Cup 2022

4 Business Sectors Reaping Sweet Profit from FIFA World Cup Qatar 2022

The 2022 FIFA World Cup 2022 in Qatar will generate roughly US$6.5 billion in revenue, topping the previous record of US$5.4 billion from the 2018 World Cup in Russia. Thanks to the once-in-four-year tournament, Qatar’s GDP is estimated to grow by 4.1% in 2022, and the tournament alone could add up to US$20 billion to Qatar’s economy.

Transparency in the Post FTX World What is Proof of Reserve

Transparency in the Post FTX World: What is Proof of Reserve?

In November this year, two big league crypto businesses, FTX and BlockFi, filed for bankruptcy. FTX had a death spiral after news broke out that the Sam Bankman-Fried-owned exchange had used customer funds to make risky bets through his hedge fund Alameda Research. On the other hand, FTX was closely associated with BlockFi, with them having signed a loan agreement with each other and BlockFi holding US$355 million in digital assets on FTX.

How Do Recommendation Engines Work

How Do Recommendation Engines Work?

Picture this: You just finished a film on Netflix and want to follow it up with something similar. Luckily, Netflix comes to the rescue and gives you the perfect suggestions to continue your weekend movie binge. This isn’t just a hypothetical scenario but something a lot of people actually go through.

Quantum Computing Has a Cybersecurity Problem. Here’s How Experts Are Solving It

Quantum Computing Has a Cybersecurity Problem. Here’s How Experts Are Solving It

In 2019, Google used its quantum computer, the Sycamore machine, to prove that quantum computers can solve a problem in mere minutes. Experts working on the quantum computer found that their system could execute a calculation in 200 seconds, whereas a standard computer would take 10,000 years to complete. What on earth is this powerful tool?

Here Are Some Alternative Sites People Are Jumping To

Musk May Have Killed Twitter: Here Are Some Alternative Sites People Are Jumping To

Ever since Elon Musk purchased the social networking site Twitter for US$40 billion, things haven’t been looking too good for the company’s future. Not only did Musk fire over 50% of the employees soon after stepping on board as the new chief executive officer, but he also intends to allow maximum freedom of speech. This can end up making Twitter a cesspool of racism and misogyny, as well as other forms of hate speech.

How Do Venture Capitalists Choose Which Project to Invest In?

How Do Venture Capitalists Choose Which Project to Invest In?

For those in the entrepreneurial space, raising funds can be very challenging. Not only is it difficult to find the right investor for your startup, but it is also hard to convince said investor to put money into your venture. With over 75% of venture-backed companies failing, the venture capitalist (VC) you approach is taking a serious risk when putting their money into your startup.