What Are Dark Patterns and Why Google, YouTube & Facebook Are in Trouble for Them

What Are Dark Patterns and Why Google, YouTube & Facebook Are in Trouble for Them

Google and Facebook could face further penalties if they don’t change their practices.

There’s no doubt that Google and Facebook are two of the biggest tech giants in the world. But recent revelations about their use of deceptive design patterns, or dark patterns, have put them in hot water with regulators and consumers alike. 

Decoding dark patterns

According to DarkPatterns.org, dark patterns are tricks used in websites and apps that dupe you into doing something, such as buying or signing up for things, contrary to your intent. Regulators and lawmakers in the U.S. and European Union (EU) are highly concerned about dark patterns and have introduced bills to crack down on their use. Below are some commonly used dark patterns:

  • Manipulative cookie banners: When you enter a website, you will usually be asked by the cookie banner whether you want to allow cookies for browsing the site. Some cookie banners are designed to have a bigger “accept all” button, and if you want to change your cookie settings, you will have to get into another window by clicking a “manage to set” button. This makes it harder for users to reject cookies for the website. 
  • Confirmshaming: Users are shamed for not doing something suggested by the website, such as taking a survey or subscribing to a newsletter. For instance, an e-commerce website might want to collect your email address by offering you a coupon. If you don’t want to share that with the site, you might have to click a button that says, “No thank you, I don’t want to save money”. 
  • Forced continuity: This dark pattern makes it hard for users to cancel their subscriptions. Some companies, like Netflix and Hulu, might extend your subscriptions without telling you and charge you automatically when the next payment date arrives.  
  • Disguised ads: Ads designed to look like part of the content on a page, making it difficult for users to distinguish between ads and the actual content.
  • Privacy zuckering: Named after Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, this dark pattern design refers to users being tricked into sharing more personal information than they intended to. Data brokering, in which users consent to companies selling your data collected by them, is a common and less obvious way to “zuck” up your privacy.

These dark patterns have one thing in common: they exploit human psychology to get us to do something we wouldn’t normally do. Now that you know what dark patterns are, let’s delve into how they have brought Google and Facebook into huge trouble.

Google & Facebook fined for leading users into cookie traps

In January 2022, France’s National Commission for Information Technology and Freedom (CNIL) hit Google, YouTube and Facebook (now Meta) with a total of EUR210 million (US$237 million) in fines over their use of cookies. CNIL has determined that these sites make it difficult for users to refuse cookies, while accepting them is as simple as a one-click button. The CNIL has fined Facebook and Google for violating the 2002-published ePrivacy Directive, or the cookie law, which defines that businesses must obtain consent before using the collected cookies for advertising purposes. If Google, YouTube and Facebook do not take steps to correct their actions within three months, the French government will impose an extra penalty of EUR100,000 a day on both firms. 

For Facebook, French users first have to click on a button labeled “Accept Cookies” to get to the second window to refuse cookies. According to the CNIL, such labeling “necessarily generates confusion“, leading users to believe they have no choice.

On the other hand, the issue with Google is one of asymmetry, not mislabeling. The CNIL points out that Google’s two services (including Google.fr and youtube.com) allow users to accept cookies with a single click. However, they must click through several menu options to reject them. 

Besides the ePrivacy Directive, another law that regulates data protection and privacy matters in the EU is the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Published in 2016, the EU law has already imposed fines of more than EUR1 billion on dishonest data collection and usage. In July 2021, Amazon was whacked by Luxembourg’s National Commission for Data Protection with a EUR746 million fine—the biggest GDPR fine—on how it uses customer data for targeted advertising purposes. Later, in September of that year, Ireland’s Data Protection Commission fined WhatsApp for EUR267 million for not being transparent about how the app used users’ personal data. 

Combating dark patterns

Dark patterns are particularly common on e-commerce sites and social media platforms where users are constantly asked to take specific actions, such as buying a product, clicking on an ad or sharing something with their friends. Besides websites, many smartphone applications also adopt these deceiving designs to collect your data. If you want to protect yourself from dark patterns, you should take notes on these points:

  • Be aware of common dark pattern tactics. 
  • Take your time when making decisions online. Don’t rush into clicking on something you’re not sure about just to get through it.
  • Be cautious of sites that require you to create an account before viewing content. You can often find the same content elsewhere without signing up for anything.
  • Use an ad blocker. This will help to protect you from some of the more common dark patterns, like forced clicks on ads.
  • Check out the privacy policy of a website or app before you use it. This may sound exhausting and redundant, but you can gain insight into how your data will be used and collected.

As dark patterns gain public awareness and regulatory attention, it’s clear that companies need to do better if they don’t want to be slapped with millions of dollars in fines. While dark patterns can boost profits or increase engagement, they are leveraged to trick and mislead users, ultimately breaking the trust between companies and customers. In the future, it’s important for companies to be more transparent about their design choices and to stop using dark patterns.

Header image courtesy of Pexels


Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email


Step Into Tomorrow: Explore the Wonders of InnoEX 2024 in Hong Kong

In the bustling city of Hong Kong, where over seven million people reside, the call for smarter, more livable cities is louder than ever. This April, the Hong Kong Trade Development Council (HKTDC) steps up to answer that call with the InnoEX and the landmark 20th edition of the HKTDC Hong Kong Electronics Fair (Spring Edition) (EFSE). Backed by the visionary efforts of the HKSAR Government Innovation, Technology and Industry Bureau and the HKTDC, these tech expos are set to feature the latest and greatest innovation from over 3000 exhibitors from more than 20 nations and regions. 

Cloud Software Group and Microsoft Forge Strategic Cloud and AI Partnership

Cloud Software Group Inc. and Microsoft Corp. have announced an expansion of their long-standing collaboration through an eight-year strategic partnership. This partnership aims to strengthen the go-to-market collaboration for the Citrix virtual application and desktop platform and facilitate the development of new cloud and AI solutions. As part of the agreement, Cloud Software Group will commit US$1.65 billion to Microsoft’s cloud services and generative AI capabilities.

The Best 4 Hardware Crypto Wallets of 2024

After a long crypto winter since the spring of 2022, the crypto world has been buzzing with activity recently. In January, the U.S. saw the approval of Bitcoin ETFs; on March 14, Bitcoin’s price soared to an all-time high of US$73,835—obviously, there is an upsurge in interest in the crypto market. 

SUNRATE Empowers B2B Transactions with Apple Pay Integration

SUNRATE, a global payment and treasury management platform for businesses, announced the integration of Apple Pay for its customers, offering a safer and more private payment method. This move leverages the advanced security features of the iPhone to protect transactions and aligns with the growing demand for seamless and secure business transactions.